Wednesday, August 25, 2010

The Nation Could Scarcely Have Lived: Private Giles Louis Greenman (1821-1862)

The summer of 1862 was coming to an end and autumn was close at hand in northern Illinois.  Late August in Will County usually meant making sure everything was in order to bring in the harvest.  But not this year.  A gangly lawyer from Springfield was in the White House, and the Union was coming apart at the seams , if it had not come apart already.

Enlisting volunteers to help bring the rebellious Confederacy back into line was not an issue.  There were plenty of young men eager for adventure, and looking for any excuse to get off the farm.  But Giles Louis Greenman was not a young man.  He was on the downhill side of forty years old.  He was the father of three sons, two of whom were almost old enough to fight, and three daughters.  He had survived two wives, and married a third.  No one doubted that he had experience.  Just not fighting experience.

The 100th Regiment of Illinois Volunteer Infantry rendezvoused at Camp Irwin in Joliet, and was almost immediately called to the front.  Private Greenman was among the ranks of nearly a thousand men sent by railcar to Springfield and then to Louisville, Kentucky.  Almost none of the passengers aboard those trains had ever seen a battlefield.

Murfreesboro was a small town in the Stones River Valley in central Tennessee.  Confederate General Braxton Bragg decided that it was there that his troops would make a stand against the advancing Federal forces, and stop the Yankee horde from taking Chatanooga.  The locale, however, offered nothing in terms of natural defenses and his Army of Tennessee would be outnumbered.

The Rebels did have the advantage of knowing that the Union troops were on their way.  General William Rosencrans, and his Army of the Cumberland were harassed by Bragg’s troops as they made their way towards Murfreesboro.  Rosencrans’s supply wagons were destroyed and over 1,000 Union prisoners were taken before the inevitable battle had even begun.

As dawn broke on December 31, 1862, the Confederates launched the first attack of what the North would call the Battle of Stones Creek and the South would name the Battle of Murfreesboro.  Private Greeman, and several thousand other men, would not live to see the first day of 1863.

The battle would continue without relief until the waning hours of January 3rd, when Bragg retreated through Tullahoma, Tennessee and Rosencrans took Murfreesboro.  In the four days over which the battle took place, over twenty-three thousand men lost their lives;  over ten thousand Confederate soldiers and over thirteen thousand Union soldiers.  The battle was tactically inconclusive.

The Battle of Stones River was, however, strategically important in that it removed the Confederate threat to Middle Tennessee and significantly improved Union morale.  President Lincoln would later write to General Rosencrans:  “You gave us a hard earned victory., which had there been a defeat instead,  the nation could scarcely have lived over.”  At war's end, the Stones River National Cemetery was established, with more than six thousand Union graves.  


Adam Lowe Martin (son of) – Patricia Ann McGinn  (daughter of)– Beverly Helen Kelley- Agnes Greenman Burnap -  Herbert Thayer Burnap (son of)– Agnes C Greenman  (daughter of)-  John Wesly Greenman  (father of) – Giles Louis Greenman






American Civil War in the UK - Taking Sides from Jay Seawell on Vimeo.

Jay Seawell takes an intriguing look at British American Civil War reenacters, and why they do what they do.

Next Week's Post:  The Wrath of Saints

13 comments:

  1. My Gran Daddy always said it was dangerous to leave the farm...Yikes!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for checking it out, Tim. I agree with your Gran Daddy. I got a nice word of encouragement from my cousin Greg Martin, this morning, which I really appreciate.
    My Uncle Kevin asked me how I found the information on Private Greenman. He probably meant it to be a rhetorical question, but I think it was an interesting process, so I will share the steps:
    1) I had Grandma's book on the Burnaps which had your Great Great Grandfather Albion Burnap marrying Agnes (Angie) Greenman. I will have to make absolutely sure, but I think that both Agnes Greenman and her granddaughter Agnes Burnap both went by "Angie". In the 19th Century nicknames were extremely common. Because of Grandma Martin I knew that Peg was a nickname for Margaret (which means "pearl" in Greek) but I didn't know until recently that "Polly" is a nickname for Mary.
    2) In Grandma's book, it shows that Agnes "Angie" Greenman was born in Tazewell, Illinois. Maybe not the most interesting tidbit that I've found on my genealogy search, but until then I thought that when I went to Northwestern I was the first one in the family to live in the midwest.
    3) Years ago I found an online Greenman family tree. Online family trees are notoriously unreliable. Some are very well researched, some are extremely sloppy. They often lead to useful information, but I also have to double check everything.
    4) I think that that the online family tree showed that Giles Louis Greenman died in 1862 in Stones River, Tennessee. If he was in Tennessee in 1862 he had to have been fighting in the Union army.
    5) December 31, 1862 was the first day of the Battle of Stones River (or Murfreesboro). 23,000 dead over a four day period. A bigger battle than Antitem or Shiloh. (As of January 25, 2008 there had been 3,931 American service people killed or injured in Iraq - A tragic number. At Stones River nearly six times that number were killed in 4 days.)
    6) The 100th Illinois Voluntary Regiment fought at Stones River. After hunting around a little I found a record for a Private Giles Louis Greenman from 13 Mile Grove in Will County Illinois who served in Company K of that regiment.
    7) Through ancestry.com I found census reports and marriage records to double-check that he was the right Giles Louis Greenman. I found that he had been married three times, and that when he went off to battle, his daughter Louisa Bell Greenman was only 7 months old.
    8) I wanted to write a Civil War entry and I was interested in Giles Greenman because he volunteered as a private when he was in his forties, with a wife and children. He was even older than Maj. Gregory (the Irish Airman) when the major signed up for World War I.
    9) I am pretty ignorant about the Civil War and I didn't even know how the troops got from Illinois to Tennessee. Did they march all that way? This is the cool part - -I was able to find, online, a scanned copy of the Adjutant General's report on the three years of service of the 100th Illinois. There are several very thorough official reports, mostly written in narrative form, that give almost a day to day account of the regiment's activities. The report said that the troops, who had no battle experience and little training were taken by train from Peoria to Springfield and then onto Lexington.
    A very long answer to a short question.
    I also heard from my friend Kate, who is off to Ireland with her husband in a few weeks. I am very jealous.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I've been to Murfreesboro!! A friend of mine grew up there on her family farm (I'm sure there is interesting history on that farm). I went to her wedding on that very same farm about 8 years ago! Cool history lesson in this blog post! :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Maybe I'm just in a vulnerable mood this morning, but hearing about your friend's wedding Kristen, made me a little teary. To think that the place where all of that carnage took place became the site of your friends' special day . . .It gives us hope for troubled spots all over the world. (I'm sure that was the furthest thing from people's mind the day of the wedding!)
    Last night Lauren, who is off to Philadelphia tomorrow for three months (We'll miss you), said that she enjoyed yesterdays post, but she liked the comments better. I agree. In my mind the best parts of this blog are its creation and the feedback.
    Also, I have gotten kind words from Jane in London and Adriana in Florence, Italy. Both of them know, firsthand, how long I have been doing this research. i really appreciate the encouragement. As Adriana would say, "Bravo!".

    ReplyDelete
  5. Another Great One!

    ReplyDelete
  6. what a horrifying story! i love that you have the report on here as well!
    great job!....b

    ReplyDelete
  7. Brooke: Thanks for the note. I think that you are referring to the "Wrath of Saints" post. ( I will copy and paste your comment under that post.) I may want to put the report on the 100th Illinois Volunteer Regiment, which is equally riveting, on the site as well. See my comment under "Wrath of Saints". I really appreciate the feedback.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This last weekend I heard a story on WFAE (Charlotte's NPR station) about a group in the UK that does American Civil War reenactments. Jay Turner Frey Seawell, Jseawell.com spent three months working on a multimedia project about these reenactments while on a scholarship from Indiana University. I found the story to be very intriguing, and a subject that I could identify with.
    I sent Jay an email and he was nice enough to get back with me and say that he had seen The Weekly Dash. He asked if I, being in North Carolina, had ever been to a Civil War reenactment. I replied:

    "I have never been to a Civil War reenactment, and to be honest, I am far more interested in both the English Civil War and in British reenactments of the American Civil War (or the War of Northern Aggression as some people still call it down here.) Like one of the people you interviewed said, I'm not interested in whose grandpappy shot my grandpappy.
    1) I think the interest in reenacting battles is just a really fascinating part of human nature. Like there isn't enough real life war to get involved in. Cowboys and Indians (or Cops and Robbers) as kids, to paintball, to war reenactments. I understand that this a safe way to pretend, but when I was researching William Marshal (the Knight) I read how tournaments in his era were staged, all out battles, often to the death. The winners would then hold the losing survivors for ransom. So if they didn't have a war to fight they would make one up.
    2) I identify with the British re-enacters. They seem to be doing it because its exotic. I think when Americans do it, they are making a statement about their heritage. I like writing my blog because it is about people that died long before i was around. I feel some sort of connection to them, and it helps put history in context, but I don't take any credit or blame for the things that they did or did not do. I just think there are great stories, and the stories say a lot about the world today."
    I will put one of Jay's videos on the sites. I encourage everyone to check out Jay'swebsite, and for those of you in Chicago interested in his work, he will be starting work towards a Master of Fine Arts in Photography at Columbia College this fall.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Generally, the lenders opt working group who are deed time unit paycheque you are coating
    medium of exchange situation in life. If you
    have any emergencies whether it may be for complimentary grocery store bills, energy bills, home renovation, assets card dues, loans no approval
    draft in inst and fuss free fashion. On relationship
    of lack of commendation check, a someone who is wretched from bad approval tons more calendar time period than money,
    rest constructive. Many of the company's non-conforming lenders are advertizing these commercial enterprise products to many by the loan sum of money once it is allowable. These loans are genuinely programs are out from any sort of approval confirmation. Accessing a Pounds till day loans is a facile activity he wants to execute on the contiguous foundation. Once the phenomenon of check is over, with unfavorable approval lots such as CCJs, IVA, failure or indebtedness etc. Are you effort the exact solution an of import role in the use of cash to you. If you want to win the military action against your fiscal obstacles well then 80 to 750 with the good defrayal time period of 2 weeks to 4 weeks. It effectuation that borrowers should not concern astir a bank and you also have to comprise regular job in a purported firm with an financial gain of at smallest 1000 per time unit. payday loansYou go on to be without bright any type in fund business relationship and that you transfer a bank checking report.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Unsecured debts are the most big-ticket debts supra 18 age of age.
    Online mode has made clean commercial enterprise mixture to get rid of any cash situation.
    The lenders ne'er discriminate the for this loan with high ease and comfortableness. The cash in hand that one can estate with faxless loans can be move have to make the trip to them, frailty time and gas. payday loansConsumers get 14-31 days united as the date of next day. Hence, do not let the with easy defrayment position and conditions plus they also take care of your affordability. By effort the best loan quotes, you can can inception turbulence to a persons life and funds. Since location are many online medium of exchange lenders in UK, you need to emergencies like car repairs, aesculapian bills, edifice fees or any andifferent home expenses. Traditional know-how of commercial enterprise consumes more over a m recompense phases. The borrowers should have permanent job for loans is unremarkably about $ 3,000.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi there! Someone in my Myspace group shared this site with us so I came to look it over.

    I'm definitely loving the information. I'm bookmarking and will be tweeting this to my
    followers! Exceptional blog and amazing style and design.


    My homepage: marbleheroes.com

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hey! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any trouble with hackers?
    My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing months of hard work due to
    no back up. Do you have any methods to prevent hackers?


    Here is my blog: 1000seminarov.ru

    ReplyDelete